Shia did a damn good job...and this is coming from someone who isn't a huge Shia fan.

Yep, I grinned when Indy said to Marion, "They weren't you, honey." It was a nice touch that, even though both of them had moved on and been relatively happy, they never got over each other. And it was cute at the wedding that when the minister said, "You may kiss the bride," Marion handed the minister the bouquet and jumped on Indy.

Cate was really good. Much, much better than she was as Galadriel on Thorazine (though of course, it'd be hard for her to be worse). Anyway -- she was clearly relishing her role. I guess you could say she's the "Darth Maul" of the Indy series -- a baddie who serves their purpose and then croaks, although they're so charismatic you can't help but want to see more of them.